John Button RIP

Former Hawke Government minister John Button has died of cancer. ABC News describes his career as follows:

He served as the Minister for Industry and Commerce under Bob Hawke and Paul Keating.

He played a key role in opening up car manufacturing to foreign competition.

He was also the man who tapped Labor leader Bill Hayden on the shoulder and paved the way for Bob Hawke to become Prime Minister in 1983.

His memoir As It Happened details his long involvement with the ALP, as well as his ministerial days. It was highly entertaining and quite reflective, two unusual traits in the writings of former politicians.

He’ll be missed.

UPDATE: Mark has an eloquent tribute from Paul Keating in comments.

Share this...
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • e-mail

31 Responses to “John Button RIP”


  1. 1 AmbigulousNo Gravatar

    Vale John Button

    What a feisty and perceptive and effective politician. Helped in the fight to remove the Victorian Dinosaur Oligarchy from control of the Vic ALP; his small group finally wrested power from them with the assistance of E.G. Whitlam, Clyde Cameron et al. This watershed alone then credited as a major factor in the ALP Federal election victory of 1972.

    In his memoirs he describes encountering narrow-minded CPA girls at Melbourne Uni in the early 50s (ex-MLC girls); thank heavens he joined the social democrat ALP rather than the CPA.

    Many thanks John Button,
    rest in peace.

    cheerio

  2. 2 MarkNo Gravatar

    That’s sad news indeed. Also sad to learn that he died of pancreatic cancer, which I understand is particularly awful.

    I had a lot of time for the guy. His own record, and that of the “participants” and Independents that he was associated with in the Victorian party – and the Centre Left – should be a refutation of all the crud about “the dregs of the middle class” that those unfriendly to the labour movement often dredge up with the obligatory Beazley senior quote. Button and his factional allies showed the contribution that could be made to politics and public policy by independent minded folks.

  3. 3 Paul BurnsNo Gravatar

    Sad to see him go.

  4. 4 Paul NortonNo Gravatar

    thank heavens he joined the social democrat ALP rather than the CPA

    Although if he had joined the CPA he probably would have been expelled in 1956 for holding revisionist views on the invasion of Hungary and for thinking the Khrushchev secret speech was genuine.

    Apart from that, what Mark said. Some of Button’s policy positions were a bit conservative for my tastes, but there’s no denying that he was a decent person and a formidable intellectual force in a government which had its fair share of them.

  5. 5 Pavlov's CatNo Gravatar

    I’m very sad to hear this news too. He was a terrific bloke — clever, rational and civilised.

  6. 6 KatzNo Gravatar

    A great lover of the Geelong Football Club:

    Through the dark ages, which began in the late ’60s, serious Geelong supporters kept themselves buoyant with gloom, stoicism and solidarity. Before the 1989 grand final one of my sons wrote to me from New York counselling me against optimism: “Despair we can handle; it’s the hope which kills.”

    http://www.theage.com.au/news/opinion/festival-for-the-fringe-of-geelong/2007/09/27/1190486478709.html

    2007 was a wonderful consummation.

  7. 7 thomasrNo Gravatar

    He was an old school mate of my old man. I remember being enormously surprised when they bumped into each other (with teenage me in tow) and chatted away about everything and nothing while waiting for a flight.

    After John left I asked my old man just who that was. “That, my boy, is the federal industry minister”. I was impressed!

    Years later, this initial meeting lead me to buy, on a whim, Button’s book about post parliament life “On The Loose”. A great read.

    Vale indeed

    Tom

  8. 8 VirginiaNo Gravatar

    Thanks for noting his love of the GFC Katz – I was lucky enough to have a couple of conversations with him in recent years, and they always turned quickly to the Cats. They should be in the black armbands this weekend for their biggest fan.

  9. 9 joe2No Gravatar

    Another blow for us tiny people.

    He were cute as a button, hit well above his height and seemed like a good bloke, for a politian.

  10. 10 AmbigulousNo Gravatar

    Well, good that he lived to see the Cats triumph last year then!

  11. 11 Paul NortonNo Gravatar

    I might add that on one occasion, when I was a febrile 20 year old anarchist, I had the opportunity to tell John Button, at a public meeting, thet his views on a policy issue (higher education funding) were a bit conservative for my tastes. He was very courteous and rational in his response, although we ended up agreeing to disagree.

  12. 12 FineNo Gravatar

    He seemed a lovely bloke. Warm, sceptical and witty and he sure could write.

    At least he got the double last year; the Cats and the ALP.

  13. 13 AdrienNo Gravatar

    Yeah I met him once. He was promoting his memoirs. He was a tough old buzzard. Polite enough but weary man, real weary. He’d seen it all thru the yellow windows of the evening train.

  14. 14 MarkNo Gravatar

    Here’s what Keating had to say in Crikey late this afternoon:

    John Button is a real loss to the country and the Labor Party alike.

    A lawyer who inhabited the centre ground of Victorian Labor politics, he was material in returning the pendulum of Labor politics from the left, where it had stuck fast for a quarter of a century, to the political centre.

    A consequence of his work within the Independents’ group was the advent of the Cain Labor government and with that change, the underlying fabric of Victorian politics returned to the Labor fold, where it has more or less remained, for just on thirty years.

    A person needs a lot of horsepower to be at the forefront of such a change, and while it was not all John Button’s work, he left his fingerprints on all the important bits.

    In his prime, he was more or less despised by the left and the right. In the swing position, he played corner politics with cunning and élan. Some would say too cunning, others mercurial, while the impartial onlooker might say inspired.

    As a Senator, he was a member of the post-Whitlam government group lead by Bill Hayden in 1977. That group, the reform ministers of the 1980s and early 1990s, came together as a coherent unit out of conviction borne by the defeat of the Whitlam government and the fact that post-War growth, worldwide, had collapsed from the mid 70s in the context of hyperinflation.

    John Button like every other member of the group knew that the old closed way for Australia, the old Australian economic defence model was coming to an end. Like the rest of us, he was not sure what should take its place but he knew it had to be something competitive and more open.

    As a person with a background in legal issues, including such things as civil liberties, it was a surprise to us all that he asked Bob Hawke for the Ministry of Manufacturing Industry. I remember going to his office after our swearing in and saying ‘what are you going to do with this job?’ He said ‘I dunno; something! God knows, something needs to done.’ Pretty much reflecting the mood of most of us.

    Button was a case book example of giving a complex job to a person with a good mind, one formerly unsullied by its complexities, leaving the mind to sift through the issues, while coming to a new set of conclusions. As it turned out, he was the Minister for Manufacturing Industry at the fulcrum point of that industry’s development and history.

    He and I had great battles over tariffs and for the tariff reductions announced in the May Statement of 1988 and the Industry Statement of 1991. But he knew the reform mantle meant he had to see his constituency’s interests in a longer term perspective. I remember calling him at home one Saturday morning in 1991, urging on him a further reduction in general manufacturing protection to 5% by the year 2000. I said ‘come on John, in for a penny, in for a quid’ and in a measure of all that was good and brave about him, he said ‘why not?’.

    He drove a hard bargain at the Cabinet table on adjustment packages for particular industries, perhaps best known being the car industry, but being prepared to play the game, whilst being charming with it, I found him, at once, exasperating yet irresistible.

    He was a fully paid up and foundation member of the reform group of ministers, the one that changed Australia forever. Deep personal losses in John’s life meant his heart and mind were always vulnerable to issues which affected the needy or those less well off.

    He had a large group of friends and political associates and of course, many he picked up in his lifelong support of the Geelong Football Club. He was a warmly regarded person, yet for all that, he was always a loner. An intellectual loner and a political loner. None of us held that against him, because the same epitaph may be stuck to so many of us.

    For all that, he held firmly to one idea throughout his life, and that was that political life was the highest calling, within which great things could be done; where the greatest leverage existed. And as his life’s work attests, he stuck to that idea with enthusiasm and perseverance.

    John Button is gone but he will not be forgotten, inasmuch that at some point, we are all forgotten. Those of us who were close to him will always remember his penchant for devilment, for the zany and the unpredictable, but also the fun in being around such a quixotic character.

    PJ Keating
    8 April 2008

  15. 15 FineNo Gravatar

    That’s such a lovely and heartfelt tribute. It gives a real sense of the man and doesn’t indulge in cliche.

  16. 16 NabakovNo Gravatar

    Ah yes, John Button, the only Australian Cabinet minister in living memory that you’d want to pick up, put in your shopping bag and take home.

    Last time I saw him was at an Australian Universities Alumni pissup at Melbourne Museum about five or six years ago. Even though he was five foot tall and nearly 70, he still had no problem attracting a bunch of throughly entertained women to listen to him telling yarns in his great mellow smoky voice.

    His “Flying The Kite” is a great read. Which also features a cameo appearance by Nick Gruen.

    They never made politicians quite like him before and I doubt they will again.

  17. 17 AdrienNo Gravatar

    Is there anyone who actually didn’t like John Button?

  18. 18 sandyNo Gravatar

    I say rest easy as a true labor mate. I just love my new cheap Korean car.
    thanks again from those like me that you helped so much.

  19. 19 janeNo Gravatar

    So sad that he had pancreatic cancer, it is a particularly nasty one.
    Vale to a great intellect and a man with the vision and energy to reform the industrial sector of this country. His legacy lives on.

  20. 20 BrianNo Gravatar

    That’s a wonderful tribute by Keating. It says a lot about both of them. It seemed to me he was a straight shooter and told it like it was.

    Speaking of straight shooting, there was a nice bit on the TV news tonight where they showed Button at a press conference on resigning from Parliament in 1993. He said he’s miss many of the people, but there were a few he wouldn’t miss, epecially if he had a shotgun in his hands!

  21. 21 SpirosNo Gravatar

    Button’s Quarterly Essay of June 2002, What Future for Labor? should be re-printed sand re-read. The fundamental structural weakness of the Labor Party is as true now as then, and has only been obscured by Rudd’s win.

  22. 22 ShaunNo Gravatar

    Despair we can handle; it’s the hope which kills

    The perfect epitaph for a fan of any sport.

  23. 23 NabakovNo Gravatar

    “Is there anyone who actually didn’t like John Button?”

    Possibly his first few wives?

    And jayzus Paul Keating, while your Button obit contained many good and inimitably expressed points, you’ve gottta stop dictating it all while marching around your office. Or at least proof the transcripts properly. There were at least two major and egregiously dangling participles there.

  24. 24 NabakovNo Gravatar

    “They never made politicians quite like him before and I doubt they will again.”

    Wherever Button is now, I bet John Gorton is buying him the next drink.

  25. 25 Pavlov's CatNo Gravatar

    There were at least two major and egregiously dangling participles there.

    So there were, and a few feral gerunds as well. But he still writes amazingly well for a bloke who left school at fifteen.

  26. 26 NabakovNo Gravatar

    You’re looking up my bum again.

  27. 27 DarleneNo Gravatar

    Spiros, that essay was a great read. Anyone who has spent more than half a minute in a school classroom enduring an ALP branch meeting knows that what he said was true.

    Vale Mr Button. Great sense of humour and a great sense of what’s right.

  28. 28 SpirosNo Gravatar

    “Anyone who has spent more than half a minute in a school classroom enduring an ALP branch meeting”

    There’s nothing quite like sitting s drafty classroom in the middle of winter freezing your bum/tits off listening to someone reading the correspondence and the minutes of the previous meeting, and then going home.

    If you sat down and designed a meeting of a political party with the express purpose of killing people’s interest in politics, let alone any instinct for political activism, you wouldn’t do it any other way.

  29. 29 KatzNo Gravatar

    So there were, and a few feral gerunds as well.

    And a schoolboy howler homophone. (That isn’t a communication device lodged up Nabs’ fundament.)

  30. 30 AmbigulousNo Gravatar

    A very ine tribute from P J Keating, focussing on Senator Button’s major role in the Hawke Govt, rather than just fondly recalling his wit and sense of fun. Amazing that John Button’s eues still sparkled after years at the top. “Age shall not weary them…”

    Earlier, Paul Norton wrote:
    “Although if he had joined the CPA he probably would have been expelled in 1956 for holding revisionist views on the invasion of Hungary and for thinking the Khrushchev secret speech was genuine.”

    Yes, Paul: most likely. The waves of resignations around Hungary, (then later around Czechoslovakia in ‘68)… but then wasn’t there a fairly steady drop-out rate, say after the Great Patriotic War had been won in 1945, and the Depression became a distant memory?

    Completely OT, but I’d be interested to hear of ex-CPA persons doing well in the ALP, even gaining Parliamentary seats. Jean M in Victoria? Jenny G in NSW? Others?? The reason I’m interested is, we hear so much about other renegades such as Ian Tuner (later Prof) and Stephen Murray-Smith (later Prof) and writers like Frank Hardy, Dorothy Hewett.

    cheeio

  31. 31 Graham BellNo Gravatar

    Everyone:

    Sorry to speak ill of the dead – but I didn’t like what Button did.

    That said, I am bloody-well annoyed that much of the “prosperity” claimed to have come about through what was done by Howard, Reith, Costello, Abbott and all that mob was actually a result of the changes that had been brought about by Hawke, Keating …. AND JOHN BUTTON.

    The other bunch just got a free ride on the results of all the radical changes that Hawke, Keating and Button had already carried out. Oh yes, they did add a little bit of brummy ornamentation – like the Waterfront Dispute, AntiWork [Choices?], 457 visa dodginess – but absolutely nothing substantial.

    Australia has indeed lost one of its most influntial politicians ever.

Leave a Reply

Please read the comments policy. If you would like an icon beside your comment, please register a Gravatar.

There is a Comments Preview function below the typing box which activates when you start typing.

Allowed tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Examples:

<strong>Strong</strong>= Strong
<em>Emphasized</em> = Emphasized
<a href="http://www.url.com">Linked text</a>= Linked text
<blockquote>Quoted Text</blockquote>