« profile & posts archive

This author has written 220 posts for Larvatus Prodeo.

Return to: Homepage | Blog Index

No responses to “Tamworth stompdown”

  1. Darlene

    Yes, Pauline really does speak for the people.

    Hmmmm, yeah haw, don’t want no darkies moving down here, they might abuse OUR womenfolk before we get the chance to do it, yeah haw.

  2. Kenny-Lee Scruggs

    Yep, blind prejudice is a terrible thing, all right.

  3. jo

    had two ‘white’ friends who lived and worked in twangworth for four years & were heavily involved in community stuff – not a nice place, and you’re never a local according to them.

    they previously did a couple of years in Dubbo – which they said was v. different and were warmly welcomed etc. Some country towns are just shit holes.

  4. Amanda

    Nooooooooooooooo PC! Don’t bring the Banjoman into this. Bag Kenny and Lee all you like, but leave Mr Earl Scruggs out of it!

  5. Kate

    I have lots of family in Tamworth and I worked there for a short while. It can be a very closed-minded community.

    I have a theory about country centres: the ones with universities are good, the ones without aren’t so good. Orange: meh. Bathurst: much nicer (though not at race time). Tamworth: meh. Armidale: much nicer. Dubbo is improving rapidly, it’s had a uni for about a decade now, but that’s also because it’s slowly sucking the life out of smaller regional towns.

    Anyway, I can state 100 percent that no-one in my small home town would welcome Sudanese refugees, despite a local white community that suffers from high rates of driving offenses, domestic violence and so on. It’s okay if white people do it of course.

  6. Stuart Lord

    I can understand why they feel against African immigrants, what with the experience they have had with those already settled there, but I don’t accept it as a positively valid reason for rejecting further immigrants from settling there, and they should pull their heads out.

    However, there should be some way to deal with immigrants who are up for serious crimes such as rape/murder/arson/larger drug crimes etc. Obviously, if they are refugees from the Sudan, then it wouldn’t be right to send them back, but some process should be available.

  7. Christene Keeler

    From today’s Northern Daily Leader: http://www.tamworth.yourguide.com.au/detail.asp?class=news&subclass=general&story_id=539742&category=general&m=12&y=2006

    You can make your comments to the paper online here: http://www.tamworth.yourguide.com.au/addopinion.asp?class=your say

    How councillors voted and why

    The Leader yesterday asked all nine Tamworth Regional councillors to comment on how they voted, and why, at Tuesday night’s debate over the proposed refugee resettlement centre plans.

    Council and the councillors have come under pressure following the decision amidst claims that decision has branded the Tamworth community as racist and unwilling to accept refugees.

    Councillor after councillor told Tuesday night’s meeting that while they personally didn’t have a problem with the proposal, it was their considered belief that widespread community support did not exist and that a significant proportion of the population was actively opposed to the proposal.

    Only three of the nine present expressed the view that adequate community support did exist and that the majority of Tamworthians had no objection to the proposal.

    Cr Diane Carter – voted for the refugee resettlement:

    “Ultimately, I’m very disappointed with the narrow-minded viewpoint of some my councillors and opposers of the resettlement centre.

    “I don’t believe we have the right to deny the opportunity of others to live without fear of persecution and war. It really is disappointing.

    “I’d like to think our reputation in this city and region is bigger than this one particular issue, and that people will see it as just a wrong decision made by the so-called leaders of our society.

    Mayor James Treloar – voted against the refugee resettlement:

    “I absolutely believe the right decision was made and that this is the honest response the community was seeking.

    “This is the natural reaction to such a plan, after current events. Ask the community in Cronulla, 12 months on if they want more refugees.

    “This is largely prompted by a lack of trust in government and its ability to fund and provide appropriate services to cater to these severely traumatised people.

    “If we can’t get enough psychiatrists to cater for the community’s need now, then how the hell are they going to find more to serve these families’ needs.

    “Maybe we will be labelled racist, but only for the two days the media harp on about it. Quite frankly its tomorrow’s fish and chip wrapping. It should be noted that all the people I’ve spoken to today have said thank you for the decision we made.

    Robert Schofield – voted for the refugee resettlement:

    “Firstly, though disappointed we aren’t able to offer more help to these unfortunate people, I want it known that I will stand by the end decision made by council.

    “I personally believe we have a moral obligation to help those people less fortunate than us, and that’s why I voted for the plans and why I can sleep at night. My conscience is clear.”

    Kevin Tongue – voted against the refugee resettlement:

    “The decision by council is much bigger than just branding us or the community racist and won’t change the status of this town or our friendliness to all visitors.”

    “I personally don’t want to see the events that are occurring in Sydney happen here, such as the racial slurs, and particularly those against Australian women.

    “If these people who are now coming out in support had spoken up and made their support clear, then I would have definitely liked to support the centre. But they didn’t.”

    Russell Webb – voted against the refugee resettlement area:

    “On the basis of all the feedback I received, council did make the right decision. On that alone, it was clear the community wasn’t ready [to become a refugee resettlement

    centre].

    “No-one rang me to offer their support for this issue. What are you supposed to do, when the only feedback you get is that in opposition.

    “Maybe council should have done a better job at getting the message out there and to the church and community groups.

    “I’m sad at the decision personally and I certainly don’t want to see us labelled racist. We definitely don’t deserve that. It’s just that the community demonstrated that they are not ready to be a resettlement area at this point in time.”

    Phil Betts – voted against the refugee resettlement:

    “It was a very difficult decision, but the right decision was made, based on the majority opposition we received.”

    “I hope we can revisit this issue in the near future, but at this point in time Tamworth demonstrated they were not ready to become a resettlement centre.

    “It’s unfortunate that the support being heard now wasn’t expressed earlier when the decisions were being made.

    “I’m proud to be part of a multi-cultural community in Tamworth and Australia, and I believe that most of the opposition was based on misinformation and stereotype.”

    Shirley Close – voted against the refugee resettlement:

    “It’s very unfortunate to think Tamworth’s reputation may be harmed by this decision. A large part of the community is a loving and caring community, but unfortunately those weren’t being heard.

    “Basically my heart goes out to refugees; it’s a sad sad situation but the reality is the Federal Government must get its house in order and ensure the right services and agencies are available to cater to these people’s needs.

    Using a Federal Government report that questioned the budget and services given to the African resettlement program, Cr Close said: “how can we possibly support a program that its own creator, [the Federal Govt] identified as deficient”?

    “If these people who are writing in now didn’t have time to participate in the survey and meetings at the time, then how likely will they have the time to provide the long-term help and support these refugee families will need.”

    Colin Murray – voted against the refugee resettlement:

    “My personal view is that as we live in a relatively wealthy community here in Tamworth we should be able to help these people. But that wasn’t the majority view, we’re asked to represent.

    “I think this could possibly hurt our reputation. Some of the opposition was well-qualified, but it was also very disappointing to hear the racial and derogatory comments from other opposers.”

    “I fielded a lot of calls on this matter, as did most of the others, and the clear majority was against us becoming a resettlement area.

    “I have to wonder where were these supporters when sought, as it’s all a bit late now. Had the majority been the other way, I would have gladly supported the centre plans.”

    Warren Woodley – voted for the refugee resettlement:

    “I just couldn’t believe it. I had no prior knowledge that my fellow councillors had decided to vote against it. I never even thought it could happen; I’m stunned to say the least.

    “Forget politics, just on human and moral emotions we should have approved the plans.

    “I was reminded today about Tamworth winning the ‘friendly town award’ earlier this month. How hypocritical.

    “The explanations of my fellow councillors who voted against this proposal held no substance. In fact they reminded me of the ultra-conservative, right wing guard of the past that once ruled this region.”

  8. Mark Hill

    they previously did a couple of years in Dubbo – which they said was v. different and were warmly welcomed etc. Some country towns are just shit holes.

    Dubbo is one of them. Does the name “Gordon Estate” ring a bell?

    If anyone involved in the riots and preceding violence wanted to move before the riots (or preceding violence), there would be no questions asked. Rural Australian towns take in a lot of refugees, a lot of them are sponsored by churches and so on.

    Would you want the a) Anglo racist mob or b) Lebanese racist mob living near you Phil?

    Now be honest. We all saw the “Mosman Line” on the chaser.

  9. Bill Posters

    its tomorrow’s fish and chip wrapping

    Or yesterday’s fish and chip shop proprietor.

  10. Mark

    There are about 700 Sudanese folk living in Toowoomba – a much bigger town than Tamworth, admittedly, but pretty conservative. All the reports suggest they’re valued by employers, and well regarded by many in the community, with some few lamentable exceptions (fortunately not elected to the City Council).

  11. Mondo Rock

    Stuart Lord notes: “However, there should be some way to deal with immigrants who are up for serious crimes such as rape/murder/arson/larger drug crimes etc.”

    There is Stuart – it’s called the Australian legal system. You know – the same one that applies to you and me and every other person living in Australia.

    But you didn’t mean that, did you? You meant that there should be some way to run the Sudanese out of town if they’re not fitting in.

  12. jo

    thanks christine – good to read from the horse’s mouths…neigh…

    & good theory kate, when my very old dog finally doesnt need her crunchies rationed out, i’ll be hitting the road with sprog and making hay in all towns (regional centres) with 2-tier educational institutions as per your advice.

    As for the sudanese refugees…. do they peel mangoes with their toes while bouncing kiddies on their knees like our happy pacific island friends? http://larvatusprodeo.net/2006/12/14/the-satire-it-just-writes-itself/ Maybe Caroline Overington can apply for this resettlement program for the Woollahra LGA. (Hello Malcolm darling) One in the garden, another in the maid/housekeeper area, & another to the peel the mangoes and bounce the kiddies….and they are free aren’t they?

    I dont think Tamworth’s working mums have thought this through at all.

    My point Mark Hill, was if two white working family people, who coach kids in footy and swimming etc – didn’t feel particularly welcome – then what hope for Sudanese refugees! Kate who has also lived in Tamworth & has family there – agrees it is a closed minded community.

    And you do realise that we all live near the ‘racist cronulla mob’ – they came from everywhere to join in.

    As for the Mosman thang – Woollahra likewise had one of the highest intolerance levels in a survey – but dont flatter yourself that they only are intolerant of muslims, my god, any ill-bred poor person isn’t welcome darling, and that might include you. You might be chosen to protect their property in times of strife, as upper working-lower middle class people have always done – but dont expect an invite to the Point Piper pile anytime soon. (They do however like to have some funny intelligent arty types who are often lefties, to provide a mix and some colour….I only go for the exquisite food and grog – I swear.)

  13. Mark Hill

    What Mark is talking about is the same thing I am getting to, that rural or non-metropolitan areas are quite willing to take in refugees and migrants.

  14. thomasr

    Finally, I have an excuse other than “country music sucks ” to never darken Tamworth’s door.*

    Thomasr
    *perhaps darkening their door was not the best descrption I cousl come up with.

  15. Tiddles the Cat

    I give you fair warning. If anyone tries to drag me into this, I swear I’ll screatch your eyes out.

  16. joe2

    They are a lucky bunch in Tamworth to have a mayor like James Treloar . He was quoted this morning on Auntys AM talking of the Sudanese refugees……..

    ” Oh, a different understanding of law enforcement, a different response to authority. They are very nervous people, they tend not to want to give out their name, they find it difficult to assimilate into our community because they have a fear of authority, they are used to authority being something that comes and harasses and tortures them.

    You know, even when they want to come and play soccer they are very happy playing with a soccer team, but when they had to give their name and address, they wanted to withdraw. ”

    Gee, who would have thought that and all that fear. Tamworth authority figures, when their not wearing the pointy white hats, are a relaxed and cool bunch that you should feel really relaxed with. Just hand over your name and address, like we all do. No way would they harass you ! Yes, right major.

  17. Katz

    Sudanese Lament (Traditional)

    It’s fearsome at home with your kindred and all,

    By the campfire at night when Janjaweed call.

    But nothing’s so lonesome, morbid or drear

    Than Tamworth City Council whipping up fear.

  18. Stuart Lord

    Mondo Rock – well, if non citizens do commit serious crimes, we should deport them back to their country of origin, assuming it is possible to do so. If they are citizens, then yes, the Australian legal system is the way to deal with criminality, but for non citizens, deportation seems the best option.

  19. Mark Hill

    “As for the Mosman thang – Woollahra likewise had one of the highest intolerance levels in a survey – but dont flatter yourself that they only are intolerant of muslims, my god, any ill-bred poor person isn’t welcome darling, and that might include you.”

    That was precisely the point Jo.

  20. Kim

    Mondo Rock – well, if non citizens do commit serious crimes, we should deport them back to their country of origin, assuming it is possible to do so. If they are citizens, then yes, the Australian legal system is the way to deal with criminality, but for non citizens, deportation seems the best option.

    I don’t know if this is what you mean, Stuart, but your comment implies that these non citizens should be deported before their guilt is proved – that’s the implication of an alternative to the “Australian legal system”…

  21. larry

    The real problem with race relations in america today is not racism.

    A new problem has emerged as the prevalence and vigor of racism has diminished.

    I started a blog yesterday to discuss this problem.

    http://holdingusback.wordpress.com/

  22. Kim

    That’s nice, larry, but this thread is not about race relations in America.

  23. Stuart Lord

    No, Kim, I mean deportation after conviction of serious crimes, rather than imprisonment/etc.

  24. Phil

    You mean like the Serbian guy who’s never even lived there?

  25. steve at the pub

    The Serbian Guy who lived in Oz for 36-odd years, most of that spent gathering extensive criminal form, and never took out citizenship?

    Exactly like him.

  26. Ross

    Rather than just blindly spouting accusations of racism, shouldn’t you be examining why such a divisive social policy is being forced onto resistant populations?

    In this case the mayor cited previous negative experiences with Sudanese, both cultural and criminal, as the major concern. I have no more information on the matter than what I’ve read in the media, but I ask why do you expect Tamworth residents to be tolerant of your ideology and turn around and accept what they’ve learnt to reject, yet you’re intolerant of their point of view? After all, they’re the ones who have to live with the consequences of what you (collectively liberals) are pressuring for. You sound more authoritarian than tolerant.

    Perhaps a pragmatic lesson could be learnt from settling all humanitarian arrivals in the leafier suburbs of Canberra, so that in a few years those who make the bureaucratic decisions that impact communities across the rest of the country could learn in detail their consequences, and calibrate policies accordingly; – in place of the current ‘wear it or you’re a racist’ jackboot approach.

    A humanitarian immigration intake is high-minded and progressive. But how much more high-minded would it be to comprehensively address your fellow citizens’ concerns first?

  27. Phil

    Ross, what ideology? It’s a position and perspective which comes from living in one of the most multicultural communities in Australia.

    I’m not exactly sure what Tamworth has to be afraid of. Anyway it wouldn’t be anything that hasn’t been experienced in other towns and cities that have embraced migrant/refugee populations.

    It’s called change.

    Lastly, something tells me that Australians are pretty well taken care of, we’re rich, it’s the least we can do to help.

  28. observa

    “That’s nice, larry, but this thread is not about race relations in America.”

    No it isn’t but it might be a very good insight into what’s in store for Australia, by importing such ‘black’ culture here. Certainly the mayor of Tamworth has noticed some troubling signs among the Sudanese already there. He also points out some similar troubling signs in Cronulla, when radically different cultures are forced upon one another. There’s no doubt these are unpleasant facts for some to swallow here, albeit they want the good folk of Tamworth to do all the swallowing. How morally uplifting that must feel.
    There is always a double standard among the usual suspects here. OTOH they will support aboriginal communities to try and maintain their culture and traditions, but when some Tamworth residents want to maintain theirs, the magnanimity suddenly evaporates and the R word is trotted about. What sheer hypocrisy.

  29. Kenny-Lee Scruggs

    Phil, it’s clear that the mayor isn’t speaking for all the citizens — any more than mayors usually do. (Though I must say I think he has one good point: that the Feds won’t provide adequate services to support refugees.) I saw a report on SBS news tonight, with voxpop, featuring assorted locals in the street who all said they thought it was mean and/or racist and/or simpleminded not to accept the Sudanese refugees. There was also a cop who was indignant that they weren’t accepting them, and a Sudanese resident who said he was very happy there and that everyone was nice to him.

    And SBS, I would have thought, has no reason to spin such a report.

  30. Mark

    He also points out some similar troubling signs in Cronulla, when radically different cultures are forced upon one another.

    Jaysus!

    How Australian is the desire to go to the bloody beach, obs? There isn’t one in Lakemba, old china.

  31. PeterTB

    Integrating extremely diverse cultures is hard work. Our Sudanese friends are lovely, but there is much to be done until they are self sufficient. We do our best, but have the advantage of a relatively (compared to Tamworth) large city’s resources behind us.

    I don’t think it would either the Sudanese or the rural community to force the new arrivals into a situation where the support resources are over-extended.

  32. Mark

    Where are you from, PeterTB?

  33. Christine Keeler

    “No it isn’t but it might be a very good insight into what’s in store for Australia, by importing such ‘black’ culture here…”

    Er, obs, I hate to break the bad news, but: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indigenous_Australians

  34. Bob

    No it isn’t but it might be a very good insight into what’s in store for Australia, by importing such ‘black’ culture here

    When I was still at school a few years ago, it was popular among many students who came from the Southern Asian. It’s sort of a mix between Wog culture and Black culture though.

  35. PeterTB

    Mark – Canberra

  36. robstar

    Why import more ”problems” than we have already. Its time to realize multiculturalism does not work. Australia as a whole should have looked at other countries problems with immigrants, and stopped immigration years ago.
    Apart from the Chinese, every other nationality comes here wants to change our way of life. Enough is enough. Am I a racist, probably, as are 99 percent of the worlds population. Tamworth, you’re right. Don’t talk about it, do it.

  37. Katz

    Point of information for Obby and his lefty-hating, alarmist friends:

    1. The Tamworth Council is opposed to a Howard Government initiative.

    2. The Immigration Dept is offering to settle these Sudanese, not dictating their settlement.

    3. These Sudanese are already resident in Australia.

    4. If individually and severally these Sudanese decided to move to Tamworth to settle, would you join the lynch mob to drive them out of town?

    Point of information for Sudanese persons contemplating settlement in Tamworth:

    1. Tamworth is home to no more frightened, narrow idiots than any other rural town of similar size.

    2. The attitudes of Tamworth residents are no more retroregressive and ill-informed than you would expect them to be given their ignorance of the world.

    3. The residents of Tamworth are likely to be correct that they can keep unwelcome persons out of Tamworth because very few people who know anything about Tamworth would wish to live in Tamworth. It would be prudent to allow Tamworth to die in peace.

    4. Why would you want to live in Tamworth?

  38. Chris

    Apart from the Chinese, every other nationality comes here wants to change our way of life.

    Apart from the Chinese? How times change. Remember when we were going to be swamped by Asians?

  39. observa

    “Er, obs, I hate to break the bad news, but..”
    True but you might want to ask the existing black culture if they want some more ‘bruvvers’ muscling in on their patch. I have a feeling LPers mightn’t like the answer to that one. Anyhow, leafy Canberra sounds the perfect place to du.. err integrate these new citizens into Australian society. And imagine if some of them were gay as well? Positively titillating, the thought of having a gay Sudanese refugee at one’s next Canberra soiree. They might even be able to play an obscure African instrument to boot.

  40. Mark

    Positively titillating, the thought of having a gay Sudanese refugee at one’s next Canberra soiree. They might even be able to play an obscure African instrument to boot.

    Don’t get too excited, obs. Tiddles is reading.

  41. steve

    I thought all these country towns were screaming out for renewal, scared of dying, sick of being ignored by cityfolk, annoyed about draining people back to the city, and looking to increase poulation size to allow local businesses to expand. So what is their problem?

  42. Oigal

    Interesting..Is it just me but besides general abuse here for the people of Tamworth then the general trend is the people of Tamworth should just do as every here thinks they should and bugger what they want. Perhaps they like things the way they are.

    Seems to me, if the people of Tamworth reckon their mayor is a dill then they can vote him out at the next election.

    “The attitudes of Tamworth Residents Sudanese Refugees are no more retroregressive and ill-informed than you would expect them to be given their ignorance of the world”

  43. Katz

    Seems to me, if the people of Tamworth reckon their mayor is a dill then they can vote him out at the next election

    My point precisely Oigal. Thank you for stating it so succinctly.

  44. Bill Posters

    Shorter Ross and Observa: I’m not racist, but…

  45. Martin B

    I had thought that one of the few positve stories in the whole sorry tale of refugees in Howard’s Australia had been the way that some rural communities like Shepparton had stood up and welcomed refugee communities.

    It is unfortunate that this attitude is not more widepsread. :-(

  46. steve at the pub

    Perhaps MartinB should look a little more closely into why the folks of Tamworth aren’t univsersally enthralled at having more Sudanese inflicted upon them.

    Clue for you MartinB, investigate what proportion of refugees in Shepparton have been charged with rape of a local girl, & what proportion of refugees in Shepparton are going to work, indeed, investigate what proportion of refugees in Shepparton have broken ANY laws.

  47. joe2

    Martin B , compassionate attitudes are guided a lot by employment needs. When employers needed cheap workers to pick fruit in Shep. the acceptance soon followed. These guys would have had the ear of council, if not councillors themselves, and provided the leadership. No shortage of country and western singers that I know of, and not good for Sudanese in Tamworth, sadly.

    The only hope for that region and refugees is the whiff of bad publicity that no tourist town needs or a Slim Salih who wins their tough hearts and gets them humming along.

  48. Stephen La Grande

    I remember Suzie Quatro being run outa town by the coucilc cica 1977,( never did get my money back for the concert.) Hey leave me old home town alone: it doesn’t have a racial problem never did as I recall, just little village called vegemite village, just over the track on the way to the airport, full of abos I think they called them. They might shine a little (holy night) light on racial problems for the town a a quick historic cultual reference. Seems the council is not gunna let Peel Street become Devil Gate Drive after all.

  49. Martin B

    Perhaps MartinB should look a little more closely into why the folks of Tamworth aren’t univsersally enthralled at having more Sudanese inflicted upon them.

    So because one Sudanese has been charged with a sexual assault, some citizens of Tamworth expect that other Sudanese will behave like this, and the councillors of Tamworth feel that this point of view is a valid one to represent. But they aren’t being racist…

    (And of course let’s not worry about comparing the rate of sexual assaults amongst the entire Tamworth community to those of the big bad city.)

    Joe2: Obviously I understand that demand for labour is a major factor, and I would have to confess ignorance about the Tamworth economy overall. But the point was made above that normally regional areas are crying out for population and infrastructure development. With a bit of principled leadership they could have worked on both of these.

  50. Katz

    Using SATP’s logic, the Tamworth Council should seek to exclude all males from Tamworth because 100% of Tamworth’s rapists are male.

    See how silly collective punishment is?

  51. steve at the pub

    Silly or not Katz, that is quite possibly how some people in Tamworth see it. BTW, it is not my logic, but a guess at the logic of some Tamworth people.

    You are of course going over the top. Several males could be excluded from the list of potential rapists. It is possible that none of the following have been charged with rape in Tamworth: Males who own farms, who have white collar jobs in the city council, who have professional qualifications, who were born in Tamworth, who have held the same job for more than 10 years, who are married, who have blue eyes, & so on.

    You do rather tend to use lawyerisms, rather than logic.

  52. steve at the pub

    Don’t know of the Tamworth people are being racist or not MartinB, but you have probably put your finger right on their reasoning. Ever thought, when rushing to use the “R” word, that perhaps it is incidental that the unwanted are of a different race to most of Tamworth?

  53. Katz

    SATP, it is possible than none of the following categories of Sudanese males has ever commited rape in Tamworth: and should therefore be exempted from collective punishment.

    Left handed Sudanese males.

    Sudanese males whose height is an even number when measured in centimetres.

    Sudanese males born on a Tuesday.

    etc.

    Your illogic is still silly.

  54. lynn white

    One of my work mates said that the proposal put by Department of Immigration was for an intensive programme, which would begin with a small number, but would grow to dozens of families each year, for at least 10 years. This would mean a major reorientation of the demographics of the town.

    Does anyone know if that’s the case?

    If it is, it does put a different flavour on the debate and makes the folks seem a little bit less redneck than they are currently portrayed.

  55. GregM

    Using SATP’s logic, the Tamworth Council should seek to exclude all males from Tamworth because 100% of Tamworth’s rapists are male.

    It is possible under some circumstances for women to be convicted of rape, Katz. Perhaps the Tamworth Council should throw the whole population out just to be on the safe side.

  56. anthony

    Lynn, I see what you’re trying to say and I’ll chuck it through the empathometer-

    Dozens of families

    Let’s try again
    Dozens of Families!!!

    One more try

    DOZENS

    of

    FAMILIES!!!!!!!!!!!

    aiiieeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee[cough] eee [uh] ee

    I dunno maybe it’s a black thing

  57. steve at the pub

    Katz: If you want to see sillyness, look in a mirror.

    It is not my logic I was posting, but an attempt to understand the reasoning of some of the Tamworth citizenry.

    If there is something to what Lynn White posted, then one can easily imagine the inherent xenophobia coming to the fore with a segment of the townsfolk.

    Katz: The horn of africa types are obviously unwanted in Tamworth. This is your big chance. Is your yard/street large enough to fit them all?

  58. anthony

    Do they really only have one street in Tamworth SATP?

  59. anthony

    Oh sorry I’ve got it now, it’s a well-how-would-you-like-it-if-they-moved-into-your-street-hey?-hey? type thing, isn’t it?

    Fine? No problem? They already do?

    Help me here folks.

  60. steve at the pub

    Yeap, one street, one pub, one copper, one store, one horse. Them hayseed towns is all the same Anthony. Why I don’t know why people would want to live there…. come to think of it, perhaps they don’t, I certainly don’t, coz it is too far south, the trees & fauna speak “cold weather” in a very loud voice, but I am only one, & tend to be quite subjective about the south of this continent.

  61. Katz

    Point of information SATP. The Sudan isn’t really in the Horn of Africa. I grant you that the Sudan is adjacent to the Horn of Africa, but not really in it.

    Is it the horn thing that gets you so worked up?

    I can’t speak for Sudanese, but in the very southern neck of the woods I shiveringly call home there are many Somalis resident, who very definitely do come from the Horn of Africa.

    Somalis make up just one thread in the many-hued fabric of my neighbourhood. I won’t frighten you with a lengthy list of the other folk who live in my street and in nearby streets. And amazingly, despite this crime against nature, the sun still struggles over the horizon each morning to cast a baleful light on the collective moral depravity of our cohabiting in a spirit of live and let live.

    Pauline Hanson hates Melbourne in general, but her brain would explode if she ever visited my little neighbourhoood.

  62. lynn white

    Anthony, if you add a dozen families a year for 10 years you end up with 120 families, but dozens means you could have several hundred families. And family in refugee resettlement programmes doesn’t just mean mum, dad and little ‘uns. It means rellies too, so if we say 4 people to a family, we are getting up into the thousands. In a town the size of Tamworth, that’s going to represent a significant shift in demographics, isn’t it, especially over time, as those families grow? Tamworth isn’t a one-horse town – it’s got a magnificent main street and substantial urban development but it’s still not huge – in fact, I looked it up just now on Wikipedia and apparently the entire shire has a population of 37,000.

    I wasn’t suggesting that I had a problem with it, just asking if that was what we were talking about, rather than the media impression that this is banning a couple of Sudanese from moving to the town. If that is what we are talking about, it’s understandable that the councillors would baulk at it, even if the expression of their reservations was a little coarse.

  63. steve at the pub

    Don’t see the relevance of Pauline Hanson Katz, although I do have to wonder why anybody would want to live in Melbourne in the first place.

    Had a good yarn this morning to one of the staff who hails from Tamworth & worked in pubs there. He hasn’t been there for several months, & like most doesn’t read/listen/watch news bulletins, thus is totally unaware of any furore over Tamworth’s rejection of any Sudanese.

    However after his answer I have gone from ambivalence siding toward thinking Tamworth needs its collective bum kicked, to fully understanding why people there would not want any more Sudanese (or anything like it) refugees inflicted upon them.

    It may transpire that the both the numbers of Sudanese & the public disorder commited by them has been very much understated.

  64. lynn white

    By the way, it’s not a colour thing necessarily. I’ve spent time in New York, where there are significant clashes between locally born Afro-Americans and the newly arrived Africans – and that’s in a city where movements of people are more commonplace. Any large group arriving en masse in a settled community causes displacement and anxiety, but particularly in the country.

    Look, I think Tamworth’s council did the wrong thing, but it’s worth understanding why they did what they did.

  65. Mikey

    So 8 out of 12 have been charged with offences, rape being the most serious. That does sound pretty bad. But there are two sides to this. I wonder why the mayor went for ‘charged’ and not ‘convicted.’ Are all the trails still in progress? Or are there other factors involved (discrimination and overzealous policing.) I live just down the road in Armidale and I have anecdotal evidence to suggest that the Sudanese refugees here (wonderful people, the ones ive met) do get hassled more than most.

    Obby will no doubt pop in to tell us that these are but the joys of multiculturalism! However from my experience the attitude problem lies mostly on the side of rural australians. Racism? Well, i gotta say i was a bit concerned when the Tamworth Mayor suggested we should ask the residents of Cronulla whether they want more immigrants. As well as ignoring recent positive developments in the shire, if Cronulla Beaches White pride mob are their touchstone….

  66. anthony

    Lynn
    I think we’re dancing around the line of understanding and understandable.
    Lets say 300 families, five each, over 10 years. That’s 1500 extra people, which all things being equal, is a 5% change in population. Does that sound unreasonable to you?
    But more’s the point, what they actually rejected was a one year trial with five families.

    Steve Steve Steve Steve Steve
    Wrong person for the ‘you city folk just don’t understand’ routine amigo. Grew near a town of 20 in the here-be-dragons part of Western Australia, father’s a wheat and sheep farmer and town councillor, in-laws manage a 35,000 acre wheat farm, best friend’s a rural GP, and I spend my time writing about regional food producers.
    But anyway if you want to be the misunderstood man on the land town, here’s a hanky.

    [hanky]

  67. steve at the pub

    Yes Anthony, some of my best friends are jewish too.

  68. Trav K

    I live in tamworth and have on and off for many years and i find Mayor Treloars discription “media beat-up” and understatement. Yes the majority agrees with him, no we are not racist, just ask the many other immigrants from impoverished nations in town who have gone on to become successful business owners and pillars of our community, but you have to draw a line somewhere. Our town has an ever increasing employment problem, severe lack of health services and so little water to sustain us that we risk running out in the immediate future. “But it’s only five familys a year” i hear you say, i say how big are these familys?, and how many years are we going to take them in?, till the’res no Jobs, Housing, Hospital beds or water for us and our children. Wake-up Australia, “Racist” a word easily used but seldom understood by journo’s and editors worldwide.

  69. Bill Posters

    no we are not racist

    Yes, actually, you are.

  70. steve at the pub

    There is racism & xenophobia aplenty in all parts of society, from high level boardrooms and university faculty right through to dole recipients & single mothers.

    However there is more to the Tamworth decision than an irrational dislike of the skin colour of the proposed new residents of the town.

    There is the behaviour & the perception of the behaviour, of existing residents who are of (or perceived to be of) the same tribe.

  71. Bill Posters

    However there is more to the Tamworth decision than an irrational dislike of the skin colour of the proposed new residents of the town.

    There is? But what, pray tell?

    There is the behaviour & the perception of the behaviour, of existing residents who are of (or perceived to be of) the same tribe.

    Oh, right.

    You mean racism.

    Thanks for clearing that up.

  72. steve at the pub

    Bill Posters, you seem to have a fixation with racism.

    Some have a fixation for whips, others for certain toys, & so on.

    You have a problem with a bit of fair dinkum racism?

  73. Martin B

    I’m not sure what definition of ‘racism’ SATP is using.

    Stereotyping the behaviour of people on the basis of their ethnicity. especially when such sterotyping is of a negative kind, seems to me to be dictionary definition of ‘racism’.

  74. Mikey

    SATP:

    There is racism & xenophobia aplenty in all parts of society,

    Ceratinly is. Especially if you’re Sudanese.


    Trav

    …but you have to draw a line somewhere. Our town has an ever increasing employment problem, severe lack of health services and so little water to sustain us that we risk running out in the immediate future.

    So all resettlement is out? Tamworth’s locking the town gates? Damn, the business council’s really gonna be up in arms over that. Or are you guys going to institute some sort of racial/cultural/religious preferencing system?

    Bill’s right.

  75. anthony

    Yes Anthony, some of my best friends are jewish too.

    That’s your comeback?

    My god

    what

    a

    bonehead

  76. steve at the pub

    Only place you will see a bonehead is in the mirror Anthony.

    Only two Steves posted on this thread. Neither of them used the “you city folks don’t understand”.

    Either you are on the wrong thread, or are a bonehead.

  77. Phil

    Maybe it’s time for this thread to be closed if all that’s left is boneheaded comments? Stop it! It’s festivus for Flying spaghetti monster sake!

    Anyone else got anything relevant to say?