Other aspects of World Youth Day 2008 have been discussed in previous posts which can be accessed here. In this post, I’d like to concentrate on why it is being held in Sydney at all.
Dr Paul Collins is probably one of the best known commentators on Catholic affairs in Australia. A former priest, he had his own run in with Cardinal Ratzinger and the Sacred Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith a few years ago, which didn’t stop him from writing a rather upbeat assessment of the prospects of Pope Benedict XVI’s papacy in God’s New Man. Some of the hopes he had in 2005 have now dissipated and he takes a rather jaundiced view of the Church’s prospects in his new book – Believers: Does Australian Catholicism Have a Future?
Collins is on the “progressive” wing of the Church, and to pose the question in the terms he does implies a view that Catholicism in Australia is in crisis. But it’s worth noting that view is firmly shared by the conservatives, and in fact World Youth Day’s Australian sojourn is supposed to be a big part of the cure for the faith’s ills.

Recent comments
skepticlawyer, Helen, conrad, Voxpop, Spana, Voxpop [...]
Terry, Sam, Terry, billie, billie, joe2 [...]
Paul Norton, Caroline Church, myriad74, joe2, myriad74, myriad74 [...]
Robert Merkel, Chris, Robert Merkel, Caroline Church, Paul Burns, Elise [...]
Pi, Enemy Combatant, BilB, Benedictus, Voxpop, billie [...]
Steven, Ootz, Brian, terangeree, Ootz, Elise [...]
Nick, GregM, adrian, GregM, Bernice, Ambigulous [...]
jane, robbo, Jack Strocchi, Elise, CMMC, Guy [...]
anthony nolan, GregM, RLRR, anthony nolan, Katz, La Ruée au Larousse du Roux Russe [...]
Ginja, Ginja, Mercurius, Tosca, Elise, Chumpai [...]
Jacques Chester, Fran Barlow, Jacques Chester, Jacques Chester, Fran Barlow, Ijaz [...]
Fran Barlow, Fran Barlow, dylwah, Ian Curr, Ian Curr, Fran Barlow [...]