Tag Archive for 'Crime'

Guest post by Tim Watts: “I’m not Racist, but… I’m Complacent”

My mate Tim Watts, who’s been doing some great work online on violent racist incidents in Melbourne, has provided this guest post. Previous discussion of the spate of attacks on Indian students at LP can be found here. -MB

“I’m not Racist, but… I’m Complacent”

Australians are rightfully proud of the good thing we’ve got going on here. We know that we live in god’s own country and most of us wouldn’t swap it for anything in the world. There’s nothing wrong with that – in fact I couldn’t agree with it more. However, one area in which we’re certainly not world leaders is self reflection. Most of us are pretty happy with our lot in life and don’t feel the need to risk it by asking too many questions of ourselves. As a result, we’ve made avoiding direct public discussions about the (relatively minor) imperfections in the Australian way of life an art form. It’s trite, but it’s the Australian way to dodge any issues that have the potential to make us uncomfortable with a dismissive ‘She’ll be right’ or ‘No worries’.

I had cause to reflect on this recently when I posted a bit of a spray about the inadequacy of the police response to the recent attacks on Indians in Melbourne on my Facebook profile. This deliberately direct comment provoked some very odd responses (both public and private) from ordinarily sensible people. While the content of these responses was extremely varied, they had one fairly consistent theme – a desperate avoidance of confronting the role that racism (subjective or structural) has played in these attacks.

I knew that Mark shared my frustration at people’s reluctance to confront the issue head on, so to try and keep up the momentum for addressing the core of this problem I offered to set out a factual basis for discussion and respond to some of the more common dodges that I’ve seen employed to avoid these facts.

Continue reading ‘Guest post by Tim Watts: “I’m not Racist, but… I’m Complacent”’

Something rotten in the state of Queensland?

From today’s Crikey:

There has been a certain feeling in the air of deja vu over the past fortnight in Queensland. The jailing of a former Minister, allegations that government was far too close to business, a government sinking rapidly in the polls while making “tough decisions” and, the piece de resistance, the exposure of systemic misconduct in the elite Armed Robbery Squad of the Queensland Police.

The timing of this sequence of supposedly unlikely events was interesting. Much is being made of the 20th anniversary of the release of the Fitzgerald Report. The date falls this Thursday, and Tony Fitzgerald QC himself will be commemorating the occasion with a public lecture at Griffith University.

So is something again rotten in the state of Queensland?

Lurid stories of convicted criminals wining, dining and bonking on dodgy day release jaunts supposedly to gather intelligence for the coppers dominated local press coverage. This a week after revelations of the jailed Gordon Nuttall’s bizarre plans to make himself premier — shades of Russ Hinze perhaps.

The reality, though, is more prosaic.

Continue reading ‘Something rotten in the state of Queensland?’

Cheerful and violent

As the world mourns for Michael Jackson, a “colourful” Melbourne identity is laid to rest with a tinnie of VB on his coffin. “Tupps” was the last surviving member of a Melbourne “crime dynasty” which has its own police taskforce assigned to it. This is called the Purana taskforce, the name of which I’m convinced was chosen just to make me guffaw when I hear it on the radio.

Just what is it with Victorians and their adoration of violent criminals, drug dealers and standover merchants? The same people who ring into talkback radio or post on news websites to froth about our crime epidemics and complain about too-soft sentences for drug addicts, dealers, burglars and “gang violence” (always “ethnic” gang violence), are all too happy to talk Desmond Moran up as a great guy who was just like one of us, really!.

His mother had a terrible job getting him to come in for tea. Putting his little boot in he’d be, bless him. All the kids were like that then, they didn’t have their heads stuffed with all this Cartesian dualism.

The traders are mourning “Tupps” – a “good guy” one insisted, as she watched the boys from forensics sweep up the street, inch by inch, shoulder to shoulder, working their way to Ascot Pasta and Deli-Cafe, where Moran had gone for his regular coffee. He’d sit on the street there most days.
No, she doesn’t want her name in the paper. But she wants someone to write that he had lots of friends and plenty of respect in this neighbourhood. People knew who he was, what was said, but they took him as they saw him.
“He was always the first to one to put his hand out to anyone who needed a hand. He’s been in the area for years and years, a lot of people will be very upset.”
Whenever she saw him sitting having his usual at the cafe where he died, just down the road from her shop, she’d get a “g’day, love”.

Stig: No. Never. He was a smashing bloke. He used to buy his mother flowers and that. He was like a brother to me.

As the police and others have pointed out, the media focus on the “gangland identity” angle has spawned a grotesque celebrity, epitomised by the “Gangland Matriarch” Judy Moran and the photos of her extensive wardrobe in the press. Life is imitating art. The men have been adopting Sopranos-like black suits and dark glasses at the many funerals that are a frequent event that world. Some of them, it seems, aren’t quite sure where Underbelly ends and their lives begin.

This is lapped up avidly by the same people who would be howling for the stocks to be brought back if they caught one of the poor wretches at the bottom of that food chain selling drugs to their schoolchildren. But then, the Morans and Williamses and Kanes are such lovely, old-fashioned folk at heart!

Mrs Simmel: Oh yes Kipling Road was a typical East End Street, people were in and out of each other’s houses with each other’s property all day. They were a cheery lot.

I don’t know if this celebration of (white) criminality is more rife in Victoria than other states. Maybe it’s because when we think of (white) criminal gangs we think of the Kellys (Scenery! Horses! Interesting cyberpunk armour! Robin Hood!) rather than the Rum Corps. The younger ones have Chopper Read, who has his own website, book deals and stints on talk shows. And then we wonder why some of the Yoof see crime as a viable way of life.

Guest post by Melanie Macfarlane: When I Grow Up: Taking Career Advice from the TV

MB writes: Folks might recall I mentioned about a month ago that I was judging UTS’ online journalism award. I’m very pleased indeed to publish the winning entry – by Melanie Macfarlane. You can read more about Melanie’s background and work at her webpage, and the post was originally published at NoMenClaTure.

This July, women all around the world lined up to see the movie spin off of the Sex in The City television series that has been attributed to changing women’s views about sex, relationships and fashion. But while fashionistas flitted about in their uncomfortable toe splitting stilettos, I awaited the return of another female pop icon to the silver screen.

The Right Kind of Role Model

Scully on The X Files. Copyright 20th Century Fox

She was strong, she was smart, she was cynical and she didn’t compromise her beliefs for a second, despite the all too convincing theories of an overly handsome man by the name of Fox Mulder. She wasn’t obsessed with the latest fashions and used her brains, not her boobs, to pursue her ambitious career objectives.

She was Special Agent Dana Scully and she was the heroine at the centre of the sci fi television drama, The X Files. While Mulder oozed sex appeal and crazy theories about the existence of extraterrestrials, Scully was the skeptical, forensic pathologist always there with a rational explanation for whatever paranormal phenomenon they were investigating that week. She stood side by side with Mulder as an intellectual equal. She was a sexy tomboy whose favourite book was Moby Dick and who wasn’t afraid of anything slimy, bloody or just down right gross. Scully stood strong as Mulder turned green and reached for a bucket.

I was twelve years old at the peak of the X Files phenomenon and I was obsessed with Agent Scully. I loved her and I wanted to be her. More than ten years and a degree in science later, I still have a soft spot for this sassy agent. As embarrassing as it is to admit to making career decisions based on a fictional television character, I take comfort in the fact that I am not alone.

The Next Generation

Science based crime solving programs are bigger than ever and so are enrolments in forensic science courses. Coincidence? I think not.

For the week of October 14 2008, four of the five most watched television shows in the US were crime-solving programs. CSI pulled 23 million viewers and was the most watched program in the country. NCIS came in at number three with 16.2 million, Criminal Minds at number 4 pulled 16.1 million and CSI: NY followed close behind with 15.8 million viewers. CSI: Miami, Cold Case and Bones were all in the top 20. Australia is no different. In the same week, City Homicide, CSI, NCIS, The Mentalist and Criminal Minds all appeared in the Top 20 programs. Reality based crime shows such as The Force and Border Security also rated well.

In an article for Science, forensic scientists Jason Linville and Ray Liu explain why shows such as CSI are so popular. “Hollywood focuses on the most interesting aspects of the forensic investigation. Science becomes a gimmick–a technological toy that the hero uses to find evidence the criminal surely hoped was undetectable.” Continue reading ‘Guest post by Melanie Macfarlane: When I Grow Up: Taking Career Advice from the TV’